A dose of reality for the “have not’s”

! This post hasn't been updated in over a year. A lot can change in a year including my opinion and the amount of naughty words I use. There's a good chance that there's something in what's written below that someone will find objectionable. That's fine, if I tried to please everybody all of the time then I'd be a Lib Dem (remember them?) and I'm certainly not one of those. The point is, I'm not the kind of person to try and alter history in case I said something in the past that someone can use against me in the future but just remember that the person I was then isn't the person I am now nor the person I'll be in a year's time.

The London Evening Standard had a story back in 2007 which I’ve only just seen about a cleaner who pays 22% tax on her part time wages while the people who own the company she works for only pay 10%.  It’s old news but it’s pertinent in today’s climate of fierce jealousy of anyone rich and successful.

First things first, it’s possible to reduce your tax liability through legal avoidance but not to the extent where you pay no income tax.  If you earn a wage here you pay tax on it.  What counts as a taxable income can be bent but you can’t earn the sort of money that give you a £260m personal fortune without paying tax on it.  But let’s go with what the London Evening Standard says anyway.

In the case of this cleaner and the financiers behind the company she works for, she’s paid £225 per week and pays £26.58 per week income tax and National Insurance (NI).  Her evil capitalist employer pays £11.88 per week Employers NI.  That’s £1,382.16 per year that she pays in tax and £617.76 her employer pays in Employers NI for the privilege of giving her a job.

Assuming her evil capitalist scum employer avoids all his income tax liability (which is impossible) and he only pays 10% Capital Gains Tax (CGT) on his earnings, he would have to earn only £117,000 to pay the same amount of personal tax as the cleaner which isn’t a lot for a devil-worshipping evil capitalist fat cat is it?  And his company is paying for the privilege of employing her as well as paying tax on its profits.

In more general terms, there are calls every day from the left for rich people to “pay their fair share”, fair share being entirely undefined but more than what they pay now.  The fact that the top 5% of earners contribute something like a quarter of the UK’s tax income is lost on these people who are motivated by jealousy, not common sense.  But who contributes more to the Treasury?  One man earning £200k a year or 10 people earning £20k a year?

The 10 people earning £20k will all have a tax free income of £7,475 each, the person earning £200k will have no tax free income as it reduces by £1 for every £2 earned over £100k.  So that’s £149,500 of untaxed income for the 10 people earning £20k each.

The person earning £200k will pay income tax at 22% up to £35k, 40% up to £150k and 50% thereafter.  The people earning £20k will pay £4,038 each in tax and NI in a year which totals £80,760 in gross contributions to the Treasury.  Most of the people earning £20k will also be entitled to tax credits and someone taking £50 per week in tax credits will be receiving £2,600 per year back from the Treasury.

The person earning £200k will pay £82.959 in tax and NI on his income over a year and will get nothing back from the Treasury.  So one person earning £200k contributes more in direct taxation than 10 people earning £20k each and the gap widens the more the high earner earns and more in indirect taxes (such as VAT and fuel duty) because they have a higher disposable income.


  1. Stan (222 comments) says:

    Hi Wonko
    I worked for the contributions agency, and for a little while the tax office after they were both merged.
    The steps that were taken by individuals and companies to avoid tax and NI contributions were staggering and most of them don’t appear on the balance sheet. Accountants and tax avoidance specialists are paid vast sums to move assets around – legally – and the amounts lost to the treasury were huge, certainly enough to justify paying the accountants.
    Capital gains tax is easily avoided, as long as you reinvest the money back into the company quickly you don’t have to pay it. Then all you have to do is siphon it off in a wide variety of bonuses, share options and perks.

  2. wonkotsane (1133 comments) says:

    Yep, I understand that lots of money is “lost” through tax avoidance but really it’s not lost because it was never due in the first place. Someone going bankrupt, dying or leaving the country and not paying their tax bill is lost revenue, someone not paying tax that wasn’t due is not receiving money you shouldn’t have expected in the first place. If a company didn’t avoid tax they would be failing in their obligations to their shareholders to maximise profits. The fact that there are so many loopholes is down to the amount of tax rules that exist – it can’t be bound in one volume, there are three books in the annual tax manual.

  3. revinkevin (176 comments) says:

    Tecincally the cleaner pays no tax at all her employer pays the tax for her.

  4. axel (1214 comments) says:

    is 22% not ‘BR’ (Basic Rate), if she is paying that much, she is on the wrong tax code or has a second job?

    You still work at HMIT? am i missing something here?

  5. axel (1214 comments) says:

    let me reword that, the cleaner pays 22% income tax on her income above £7,475

  6. wonkotsane (1133 comments) says:

    Well yes Kev but it does come out of her wages so she’s still footing the bill! 😀

    Axel, 22% is the standard rate of income tax and paid on any taxable income over your tax allowance. BR is 20% of all taxable income with no tax allowance. If you go over £35k then you pay 22% on taxable income over your tax allowance up to £35k and then 40% of taxable income over the £35k. If you go over £150k then you pay 22% on taxable income over your allowance up to £35k, 40% of taxable income over £35k but less than £150k and then 50% of anything over £150k.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.